| Latest Forum Topics / PARAGONREIT |
 Post Reply
|
|
SPH Reit
|
|||
|
Alignment
Elite |
07-May-2026 21:36
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
If it is the case that private markets value properties more highly than the public markets then REITs should just be privatised at a premium to current share prices by these private funds. Win win. Better than having say Keppel REIT dilute itself by trying to compete bidding against private money. | ||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Joelton
Supreme |
06-May-2026 09:27
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Paragon deal: Why investors should get ready for more Reit mergers and take-private offers In a less-conducive operating backdrop, smaller Reits may be weeded out, as larger ones play the role of consolidators THE most prosaic observation about the purchase of Paragon by CapitaLand Integrated Investment Trust (CICT) from Cuscaden Peak may also be the most profound: Among real estate investment trusts (Reits), the biggest players have an unbeatable advantage when it comes to acquiring assets and enhancing them. So, perhaps investors should get ready for more take-private deals, and another spate of mergers. With elevated inflation and interest rates weighing on yield-oriented investments and the ongoing rejuvenation of the broader Singapore market, investors will probably become less enamoured with all but the largest Reits that are exposed to the most resilient asset classes. Against this less conducive backdrop, some of the smaller Reits may be weeded out, while the largest players play the role of consolidators, scooping up assets that become available amid the shake-out. Indeed, the most striking aspect of the Paragon deal is that the manager of CICT seems much less fazed by the ageing property&rsquo s need for a costly asset enhancement initiative (AEI) than Cuscaden Peak. A key rationale for Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s take-private offer for Paragon Reit last year was that its flagship asset needed an AEI costing between S$300 million and S$600 million in order to maintain its competitiveness &ndash an exercise which would have caused enormous volatility in its distributions per unit (DPU). The manager of CICT has said it will conduct its own evaluation of AEI opportunities for Paragon, and that the final scope and costs may differ from Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s preliminary analysis. One reason for this seeming nonchalance is that Paragon is not an overwhelmingly large proportion of CICT&rsquo s portfolio a phased AEI combined with upward rent adjustments could mitigate much of the adverse impact on its DPU. CICT also has ample financial capacity to take on an asset like Paragon, thanks in part to its S$2.5 billion sale of Asia Square Tower 2. CICT&rsquo s manager noted that it is unlocking value from the leasehold office asset by selling it at a net property income yield of 3 per cent, and redeploying the capital into a freehold integrated development at a higher yield of 3.9 per cent. CICT has also raised S$750 million through a placement of new units at S$2.30 each. Exits and repositionings Cuscaden Peak was not the only Reit sponsor that felt the need to withdraw from the public market. Frasers Hospitality Trust was also taken private by its sponsor group last year, after a strategic review determined that it would have difficulty growing its distributions and net asset value (NAV) in the face of adverse macroeconomic trends and structural factors in the hotel space. Meanwhile, some sponsor groups have been trying to reposition the weaker Reits under their umbrellas, or simply selling them off. In an interesting case, CapitaLand Investment launched Shanghai-listed CapitaLand Commercial C-Reit last year. CapitaLand China Trust (CLCT) &ndash which has not been trading well in Singapore &ndash played a direct role in the exercise by taking a stake in the Reit, and seeding it with one of its properties. CLCT&rsquo s sponsor group has said it will list a second China Reit later this year, and eventually combine both the China Reits. This could create a bigger platform for CLCT to tap China&rsquo s domestic capital market, and unlock the value of its mature assets. In another case, ESR Group sold Suntec Reit&rsquo s manager to Tang Organization earlier this year. The acquiring group, which already controlled about 36 per cent of Suntec Reit&rsquo s units, said it would conduct a strategic review to strengthen the Reit&rsquo s performance and enhance its capital efficiency. In the wake of that transaction, Hongkong Land acquired 10.8 per cent of Suntec Reit&rsquo s units from ESR Group &ndash sparking speculation that it may be interested in buying some of its assets. Hongkong Land launched an S$8.2 billion property fund in Singapore earlier in the year. Among the fund&rsquo s assets are Hongkong Land&rsquo s one-third stakes in Marina Bay Financial Centre (MBFC) Towers 1 and 2, Marina Bay Link Mall and One Raffles Quay. Qatar Investment Authority&rsquo s Asia Square Tower 1 is also part of the fund&rsquo s initial portfolio. More mergers? These recent developments highlight the consolidating role that large property groups &ndash such as CapitaLand, Frasers Property and Hongkong Land &ndash are playing in the shifting dynamics of the Reit sector. Meanwhile, CICT&rsquo s acquisition of Paragon underscores the importance of the largest Singapore-focused Reits in sustaining the vibrancy of the whole sector. With their heft and the resilience of their Singapore-based assets, CICT and others like it &ndash including CapitaLand Ascendas Reit (Clar), Frasers Centrepoint Trust and Keppel Reit &ndash have helped draw investors as well as new listing aspirants to the Singapore market. With increasingly unfavourable macroeconomic conditions, the time might now be right for the largest Singapore-focused Reits to strengthen themselves by becoming even bigger through mergers. This is not a new idea. Many of the leading Reits in the market have merged in the past to gain scale. CICT was known as CapitaLand Mall Trust until it acquired CapitaLand Commercial Trust in 2020. Mapletree Commercial Trust was renamed Mapletree Pan Asia Commercial Trust (MPACT) four years ago, after acquiring Mapletree North Asia Commercial Trust. Mergers among sponsor groups have also resulted in Reits with overlapping mandates combining themselves. This happened after CapitaLand acquired Ascendas-Singbridge, and after ARA Asset Management was acquired by ESR Group. Looking ahead, the much-talked-about merger of CapitaLand Investment and Mapletree Investments could be a catalyst for Clar to subsume Mapletree Industrial Trust, and for CICT to acquire MPACT. Some groundwork will probably be necessary to stave off minority investor resistance, though. One obvious sticking point is that CICT is 95 per cent exposed to Singapore, and trades at 1.1 times NAV while MPACT is only 61 per cent exposed to Singapore, and trades at 0.7 times NAV. Still, the creation of bigger Reits, with larger exposure to resilient asset classes, could be the key to maintaining the vibrancy of the sector. |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
|
|||
|
Joelton
Supreme |
25-Apr-2026 10:32
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Does Paragon need $300 mil to $600 mil of AEI? Unitholders of Paragon REIT may have sounded somewhat miffed at CapitaLand Integrated Commercial Trust&rsquo s (CICT) proposed acquisition of Paragon mall for $3.9 billion. But they shouldn&rsquo t be. After all, CICT&rsquo s unit price rose after a trading halt on April 20, and its private placement was upsized and 4.8 times covered, evidence that institutional investors like the deal. They should take issue with the rationale for Paragon REIT&rsquo s privatisation. Paragon REIT&rsquo s scheme document dated March 27, 2025, stated that Paragon required an asset enhancement initiative (AEI) valued at between $300 million and $600 million over four years to compete with the other malls along Orchard Road. The scheme document had said: Taking into consideration the uncertainties inherent in a potential AEI, the offeror (Cuscaden Peak) believes that a major potential AEI would be more suitably carried out in a private setting. The $300 million to $600 million AEI reason for privatising the REIT came on the heels of a previous AEI completed after the pandemic. Paragon once accounted for 72% of Paragon REIT&rsquo s assets. JLL&rsquo s valuation as at the end of 2024 was $2.9 billion. |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Alignment
Elite |
23-Apr-2026 19:51
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
It would need to be a higher price than 55 cents to tempt YTL to sell. | ||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
bechaotic
Member |
22-Apr-2026 12:05
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Will CICT be eyeing on Wisma too? There Takashimaya SC beside. Starhill reit now at 55 cents, so much cheaper than the 98 cents privatised by Paragonreit. |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
|
|||
|
Alignment
Elite |
21-Apr-2026 11:31
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
CICT shareholders should be asking themselves if they are overpaying, and why they did not try to buy it much cheaper a year ago when they had the chance. | ||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Joelton
Supreme |
21-Apr-2026 11:24
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
The Paragon paradox: CapitaLand&rsquo s upscale retail mall scoop is a win &ndash but for whom? Just a year ago, investors were told that Paragon needed a massive makeover &ndash but that narrative has been flipped entirely [SINGAPORE] When Cuscaden Peak took Paragon Real Estate Investment Trust (Reit) private in the first half of 2025, the narrative delivered to retail investors was stark. The trust&rsquo s crown jewel, Paragon mall, needed a massive, critical makeover to stay relevant in a brutal retail landscape. This was estimated to take up to four years to complete, with a potential capital expenditure totalling up to S$600 million, or up to 21 per cent of Paragon&rsquo s FY2024 appraised value of S$2.9 billion as a 99-year leasehold property. Unitholders were warned that staying on board meant enduring a painful period of construction dust, execution risks and a heavily crushed distribution per unit (DPU). Faced with that bleak outlook, many Paragon Reit unitholders logically took the S$0.98 per unit cash offer and walked away. Fast-forward a year, and the script has been flipped entirely. The manager of CapitaLand Integrated Commercial Trust : C38U 0% (CICT) on Monday (Apr 20) announced it was buying Paragon mall for S$3.9 billion &ndash now on a freehold basis. And just like that, the supposedly daunting overhaul is now pitched to the market as an exciting growth catalyst. But why would Singapore&rsquo s largest commercial real estate giant pay a massive premium for a mall staring down a costly renovation? Part of the answer lies in the cold, efficient mechanics of scale. &ldquo Beyond the retail floors, CICT is buying a structural moat. A huge chunk of that S$3.9 billion price tag is justified by the medical suites upstairs. Retail can be a fickle game, completely at the mercy of consumer whims. Medical tenants, however, are incredibly sticky. &rdquo What served as a fatal DPU shock for a small, concentrated trust is merely a speed bump for a giant. With a massive, diversified portfolio across Singapore, Sydney and Frankfurt, CICT can easily absorb the downtime of an Orchard Road upgrade. For a trust of this size, an asset enhancement initiative is a routine value-add opportunity, rather than an existential threat. It has the balance sheet to fund the works, and the sheer size to mask the temporary income loss. No overhaul after all? Then, there is the fine print of the acquisition announcement, which reveals a rather amusing pivot. CICT stated it will &ldquo explore&rdquo asset enhancement opportunities, noting that Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s preliminary estimate &ndash some S$300 million to S$600 million &ndash &ldquo may differ&rdquo from CICT&rsquo s own eventual plans. This is classic corporate speak for leaving the back door wide open. It strongly hints that CICT might not undertake the massive overhaul at all, or at least nowhere near that intimidating scale. If CICT eventually decides a lighter touch is sufficient, it will confirm every market cynic&rsquo s suspicion: The terrifying existential threat used to justify taking Paragon Reit private was simply a very effective narrative to clear the room. Once the asset safely crossed over to the institutional side, the urgent need for a massive overhaul suddenly became a highly flexible option subject to &ldquo detailed feasibility studies&rdquo . This adds to the brilliance of the capital swop. CICT is partially funding this mega purchase by simultaneously selling Asia Square Tower 2 to Malaysia&rsquo s IOI Properties for roughly S$2.5 billion. Effectively, it is unloading a mature office asset at a very tight 3 per cent exit yield, representing a healthy premium to its last valuation. That capital is instantly recycled into Paragon at an estimated 3.9 per cent yield. This is a highly effective corporate manoeuvre, swopping a peaking office tower for a freehold retail trophy in the heart of the shopping belt. Beyond the retail floors, CICT is buying a structural moat. A huge chunk of that S$3.9 billion price tag is justified by the medical suites upstairs. Retail can be a fickle game, completely at the mercy of consumer whims. Medical tenants, however, are incredibly sticky. An ageing population and the steady flow of regional medical tourism provide a defensive income stream, and anchors the more volatile retail floors below. Controlling the belt There is another consequence to this massive concentration of prime real estate. CICT is effectively building a monopoly board right down the spine of Singapore&rsquo s shopping district. The manager notes that the acquisition anchors its presence from Orchard Road MRT station all the way to City Hall. When you string together ION Orchard, Paragon, Plaza Singapura, The Atrium@Orchard, Raffles City and Funan, CICT essentially owns the downtown footprint. The Reit manager has explicitly declared that the purchase cements the trust&rsquo s position as the largest owner of private retail stock in Singapore, reinforcing its leadership as the ultimate proxy for the city&rsquo s high-quality commercial real estate. The management calls this &ldquo defensive positioning&rdquo and &ldquo market relevance&rdquo in a precinct with limited new supply. In plain terms, this level of dominance hands the landlord immense pricing power. Retailers seeking premium foot traffic have very few alternatives. When lease negotiations come around, a dominant landlord can squeeze tenants for higher rents and a larger cut of their sales. Shoppers will ultimately absorb these higher costs through pricier cups of coffee and more expensive clothes. Left out in the cold? Ultimately, this sequence of events is a masterclass in how structural incentives dictate market moves. The building on Orchard Road remained exactly the same. But the incentive structure of its owners changed. Temasek-backed Cuscaden Peak &ndash a joint venture controlled by Mapletree Investments subsidiary Mapletree Fortress and Adenium, a subsidiary of CapitaLand&rsquo s CLA Real Estate &ndash bought the asset. They held it briefly, and are now passing it to CICT. While the narrative has changed, the property still sits in the broader CapitaLand and Temasek universe. Meanwhile, retail investors might find themselves on the periphery of these massive institutional wins. To lock in the deal quickly, the manager has launched a S$600 million private placement, aimed squarely at large funds. While the institutions secure a discounted entry point into a blue-chip vehicle, retail investors are unable to participate and wake up to a slightly diluted ownership stake. To be sure, the manager&rsquo s defence is mathematically sound. The deal is projected to be DPU-accretive. Retail investors own a smaller slice of the pie, but the bakery is now much larger, meaning their total payout should theoretically increase. Clearly, though, the mom-and-pop investors are unlikely to see themselves as the true winners of the Paragon deal. They may get the defensive stability of a giant portfolio. But they will be paying for it by taking on the execution risks of the new asset, and the sting of immediate dilution &ndash all for a trophy retail asset that was deemed not too long ago to be in desperate need of an overhaul. |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Joelton
Supreme |
21-Apr-2026 11:23
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
S$3.9b Paragon acquisition seals CICT&rsquo s dominance in downtown retail, adds medical exposure Deal, to be partly funded by S$2.5 billion divestment of Asia Square Tower 2 to IOI, seen as &lsquo tactical swap&rsquo may yield redevelopment potential on freehold Orchard Road parcel [SINGAPORE] The S$3.9 billion proposed acquisition of Paragon mall is set to cement CapitaLand Integrated Commercial Trust : C38U 0%&rsquo s (CICT) dominance along the Orchard Road shopping belt and downtown stretch, and also gives it a foothold in Singapore&rsquo s high-end medical sector. Aside from ownership of a prime retail asset housing luxury brands and premium medical suites, the freehold acquisition also gives CICT a line to tap into potential for future redevelopment, in an area where several redevelopment projects are planned. On Monday (Apr 20), the manager of CICT announced the acquisition of the mall from a consortium of Temasek Holdings subsidiaries, including Cuscaden Peak. The acquisition will be funded by debt, a private placement to raise at least S$600 million and funds from its divestment of Marina Bay area office property Asia Square Tower 2 for S$2.48 billion &ndash at a 9.9 per cent premium over its market valuation of around S$2.25 billion as at end 2025. CICT is selling Asia Square Tower 2 to Malaysia&rsquo s IOI Group, in what Tan Choon Siang, CEO of the Reit manager called a &ldquo timely divestment&rdquo . The sale, &ldquo at an exit yield of 3 per cent enabled us to unlock value from a leasehold office asset and redeploy capital into a freehold integrated development&rdquo , said Tan. Overall, the transaction is expected to be 2.1 per cent accretive to distribution per unit (DPU), with gearing holding steady at 39.2 per cent. Paragon is being acquired at a net yield of about 3.9 per cent, based on the adjusted net property income for FY 2025. Darren Chan, research manager at Philips Securities Research, viewed the move as &ldquo opportunistic capital recycling&rdquo rather than a structural pivot from office to retail, noting that the Reit is exiting Asia Square Tower 2 at a 3 per cent yield and redeploying proceeds into Paragon at a higher 3.9 per cent net yield. The move improves income stability by reducing exposure to more cyclical office cash flows, said Chan. &ldquo After factoring in the private placement and funding costs, the 2 per cent DPU accretion represents a modest DPU uplift for unitholders.&rdquo Vijay Natarajan, RHB Singapore vice-president of equity research for real estates and Reits, called it a &ldquo tactical swapping&rdquo of a leasehold prime office building into a prime Singapore retail with freehold interest. Buying Paragon reinforces CICT&rsquo s stronghold as the largest owner of private retail stock in Singapore, the Reit manager said in a bourse filing. CICT holds several other prime central business district (CBD) area retail assets in its portfolio &ndash ION Orchard, Plaza Singapura, The Atrium@Orchard, Raffles City Singapore and Funan. Explaining the rationale for the Paragon buy, the manager flagged &ldquo potential upside to re-rate rents closer to prevailing market levels, supporting positive rental reversions&rdquo . It also pointed to value creation opportunities beyond rental reversion, &ldquo through proactive tenant remixing to further sharpen the trade mix, optimise space allocation and enhance rental quality.&rdquo With limited new retail supply of 0.3 million sq ft per annum between 2026 and 2028 and no fresh supply along Orchard Road, CICT&rsquo s manager cited average prime Orchard Road retail rents rising quarter-on-quarter, widening the gap against suburban rents. &ldquo This positive momentum is further supported by improving tourism fundamentals, including expected year-on-year growth in tourist arrivals and tourism receipts,&rdquo it said. Paragon mall&rsquo s retail positioning &ndash with over 190 retail and lifestyle brands &ndash is also complemented by a &ldquo well-established&rdquo medical cluster of over 80 multi-disciplinary tenants. &ldquo Medical space in Singapore is structurally scarce,&rdquo it added. According to a report by Savills, there are less than 2,000 medical suites in Singapore, of which around half are located within hospitals. &ldquo The remaining 50 per cent are available in the market, which highlights the value of such medical spaces.&rdquo This scarcity, together with long-term demand drivers such as an ageing population and rising medical tourism, is expected to support sustained demand for quality medical facilities, the manager said. The building&rsquo s immediate proximity to the Mount Elizabeth medical cluster further positions it to capture medical tourist flows, it said. &ldquo These attributes have enabled Paragon to maintain consistently high committed occupancy, at or near 100 per cent, across market cycles.&rdquo Potential costs CICT is acquiring Paragon at an agreed value of about S$3.9 billion. Two independent valuations done as at Mar 31, 2026 priced the asset at S$3.895 billion (Knight Frank) and S$3.905 billion (Cushman and Wakefield). The most recent valuation prices the property as a freehold asset, markedly higher than an earlier valuation done at end-2024 when Paragon was held as a 99-year-leasehold property by Paragon Reit at S$2.9 billion. At the time, Paragon&rsquo s owner, Cuscaden Peak, had proposed a privatisation of the Reit, saying the mall needed an overhaul. &ldquo Paragon&rsquo s premier upscale status is being challenged by malls undergoing major upgrades and upcoming redevelopments in the surrounding catchment (for example, Ming Arcade, Tanglin Shopping Centre, Forum The Shopping Mall, voco Orchard Singapore, and HPL House), which are expected to significantly ramp up competition once completed,&rdquo Cuscaden Peak said in its Feb 11 statement last year. &ldquo In addition to these competitive pressures, a persistent slowdown in luxury spending post pandemic, with international luxury spending at 74 per cent of its 2019 peak, has also weighed on Paragon&rsquo s performance,&rdquo it added. A major asset enhancement initiative (AEI) was needed for Paragon to &ldquo maintain its long-term competitiveness&rdquo , but had execution risks that were &ldquo more suitably carried out in a private setting&rdquo . The AEI for Paragon, which opened in 1986, could cost S$300 million or more, Cuscaden Peak said then. The proposed AEI was expected to take up to four years to complete, and included potential upgrades to Paragon&rsquo s facade and interiors, reconfiguration of its spaces and improvements to connectivity, among others. Capital expenditure was projected to range from S$300 million to S$600 million, or between 10 and 21 per cent of Paragon&rsquo s FY2024 appraised value of S$2.9 billion. On Monday, CICT&rsquo s manager said it would undertake its own evaluation, including detailed feasibility studies and cost analysis. &ldquo Any capital expenditures going forward&hellip may differ from Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s preliminary analysis.&rdquo The mall&rsquo s last major overhaul, which cost S$82 million, was in 2009. At the time, 42,000 sq ft of space was added to the mall. The integrated development currently comprises a six-storey retail podium with two basement levels, spanning 45,691 sq m, and two medical and office towers with 20,726 sq m of net lettable area. With several redevelopments on the horizon for Orchard Road properties, the acquisition of the freehold Paragon parcel also opens up the possibility of potential redevelopment in the future. Upside and positioning With the completion of the Paragon and Asia Square transactions, about 95 per cent of CICT&rsquo s portfolio will be anchored in Singapore. Portfolio property value will increase from S$27 billion to S$28.7 billion. The manager added that the portfolio will remain &ldquo well-balanced and diversified&rdquo , comprising 32 per cent retail, 31 per cent office and 37 per cent integrated developments of retail and office assets. The share of integrated developments will rise significantly from 25 per cent, reflecting a shift towards assets combining &ldquo scale, diversification and defensive income characteristics&rdquo . The acquisition will cement CICT&rsquo s positioning as the largest Asia-Pacific Reit, with assets under management of S$29 billion, said RHB&rsquo s Natarajan. &ldquo We recommend that investors participate in the placement considering the reasonably attractive entry level of around 1.05 times of book and 5 per cent yields, with upside potential from valuation uplift and Singapore dollar fund flows in the current uncertain environment,&rdquo he added. String of divestments The impending sale of Paragon is the latest in a series of divestments by Cuscaden Peak, selling assets that it acquired from its takeover of Singapore Press Holdings in 2022. These include three freehold Nassim Road bungalows for S$206.7 million a student housing portfolio of properties in the UK and Germany worth £ 1 billion (S$1.7 billion) The Seletar Mall for S$550 million and The Rail Mall in Upper Bukit Timah Road for S$78.5 million. A third retail property, The Woodleigh Mall, has been on the market for S$800 million since July 2024. The shopping centre is jointly owned by Cuscaden Peak and Japanese developer Kajima Development. In December 2025, the group sold The Clementi Mall for S$809 million to an entity linked to Zhao Zhichao of property firm, The Elegant Group. With Paragon to be sold, Cuscaden Peak now holds just two retail assets in its portfolio: a 50 per cent stake in the integrated development comprising The Woodleigh Residences and The Woodleigh Mall, and a 50 per cent stake in Westfield Marion in South Australia. Trading in CICT was halted on Monday morning. The counter closed flat at S$2.39 on Friday. |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
|
|||
|
Joelton
Supreme |
15-May-2025 08:28
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Paragon Reit to suspend trading on May 15 ahead of delisting
[SINGAPORE] Paragon Reit : SK6U 0%will suspend trading in its units from 9 am on Thursday (May 15), and bow out of the Singapore Exchange, the manager of the retail real estate investment trust said in a regulatory filing on Wednesday.
Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s Times Properties proposed to take the real estate investment trust private at S$0.98 in February, and the scheme obtained approval from unitholders in April.
Created as SPH Reit at its initial public offering in 2013, the retail Reit counts the upscale Orchard Road mall Paragon as its crown jewel.
|
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Joelton
Supreme |
23-Apr-2025 13:24
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Paragon Reit unitholders give nod to privatisation offer
The trust is expected to delist on Jun 6 unitholders are to receive a consideration of S$0.98 per unit in cash
[SINGAPORE] Unitholders of Paragon Real Estate Investment Trust (Reit) approved the scheme resolution proposed by Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s Times Properties to take the trust private. Its delisting is expected on Jun 6, subject to regulatory approval.
During the scheme meeting on Tuesday (Apr 22), 1,000 unitholders or around 82.8 per cent of those present and voting, agreed to the privatisation offer. This represented about 97.6 per cent of units, well above the 50 per cent required of total voting minority shareholders, as well as the required 75 per cent in value of units.
The scheme resolution was also contingent on the approval of amendments made to the Paragon trust deed. These amendments, which were also voted on during an extraordinary general meeting held the same day, drew 98.8 per cent of support, surpassing the 75 per cent required to push through with it.
Paragon Reit unitholders will receive the scheme consideration of S$0.98 a share in cash on or around Jun 4.
Independent financial advisor (IFA) PrimePartners previously described the privatisation offer of S$0.98 per unit as fair and reasonable, and noted that it represented a slight premium of 4.4 per cent over the Reit&rsquo s net asset value (NAV) per unit, and a premium of 7.1 per cent over its adjusted NAV per unit.
The IFA said the scheme consideration also represented premiums of more than 10 per cent over the units&rsquo volume-weighted average prices spanning various look-back periods of up to two years.
Cuscaden Peak had made an offer to privatise the trust in February, noting that it had the lowest free floats among its retail Singapore Reit (R-Reit) peers, and had historically experienced low trading liquidity.
Total assets have grown 1.3 times since the Reit&rsquo s creation as SPH Reit at its initial public offering in 2013, compared to the average of 2.9 times for other retail S-Reits, Cuscaden added. Its cash offer of S$0.98 per unit values the Reit at S$2.8 billion.
Still, the manager noted in a bourse filing on Apr 17 that it had tried to address these issues. For instance, it undertook an equity issuance of S$164.5 million in December 2019, along with the acquisition of a 50 per cent interest in an Australian shopping centre, which resulted in an increase of its free float to about 38.5 per cent.
&ldquo Recent market conditions, such as the Covid-19 pandemic and the unavailability of assets with accretive returns limited Paragon Reit&rsquo s acquisition of quality assets, which may have resulted in the limited increase (in its free float),&rdquo said the manager.
The presence of &ldquo many long-term unitholders&rdquo could be another factor, given that the Reit has been consistently paying annual distributions of over S$0.05 since its listing, save for 2020, when the Reit was affected by the pandemic, it added.
The scheme would therefore allow unitholders &ldquo to realise their investment in cash at an attractive valuation with no trading costs&rdquo , and enable them &ldquo to immediately reinvest proceeds into other opportunities&rdquo , said Cuscaden and Paragon Reit.
|
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
n3wbie
Elite |
22-Apr-2025 23:25
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Congrats to all shareholders | ||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
MrBear12
Supreme |
22-Apr-2025 16:53
Yells: "Cast all our anxieties on Jesus for He cares for us" |
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Paragon reits SH are rational
|
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
|
|||
|
chongpin
Senior |
22-Apr-2025 16:52
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Paragon Reit unitholders give nod to privatisation offerThe trust is expected to delist on Jun 6 unitholders are to receive a consideration of S$0.98 per unit in cash Tue, Apr 22, 2025 · 04:37 PM Paragon Real Estate Investment Trust (Reit) will soon be taken private, with around 82.8 per cent of unitholders present and voting having agreed to the privatisation offer at a scheme meeting on Tuesday (Apr 22). PHOTO: BT FILE
[SINGAPORE] Unitholders of Paragon Real Estate Investment Trust (Reit) approved the scheme resolution proposed by Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s Times Properties to take the trust private. Its delisting is expected on Jun 6, subject to regulatory approval. During the scheme meeting on Tuesday (Apr 22), 1,000 unitholders or around 82.8 per cent of those present and voting, agreed to the privatisation offer. This represented about 97.6 per cent of units, well above the 50 per cent required of total voting minority shareholders, as well as the required 75 per cent in value of units. The scheme resolution was also contingent on the approval of amendments made to the Paragon trust deed. These amendments, which were also voted on during an extraordinary general meeting held the same day, drew 98.8 per cent of support, surpassing the 75 per cent required to push through with it. |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
HB8289
Master |
22-Apr-2025 14:59
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Any updates? |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
n3wbie
Elite |
21-Apr-2025 22:32
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Seems like all the analysts, IFA and board all say to accept the offer. Frankly I thought the offer was quite decent relative to other offers in the market. Of course can ask and hope for more but given this rubbish market, probably can tender and say bye to management for last time tomorrow at EGM.
|
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Joelton
Supreme |
15-Apr-2025 11:21
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Can Paragon Reit upgrade crown jewel Paragon without unitholders&rsquo distribution taking a big hit?
Find good solutions for smaller listed Reits envisaging major asset upgrading works
[SINGAPORE] As the local bourse waits for potential new real estate investment trust (Reit) listings to materialise, Paragon Reit : SK6U 0%, : SK6U 0%which went public in July 2013, might be delisted soon.
The fate of Times Properties&rsquo proposed privatisation of Paragon Reit via a trust scheme of arrangement lies solely with minority investors who meet in an extraordinary general meeting (EGM) and scheme meeting on Apr 22. If the scheme becomes effective, subject to Singapore Exchange&rsquo s approval, Paragon Reit will be delisted.
Times Properties is a wholly owned subsidiary of Paragon Reit&rsquo s sponsor Cuscaden Peak Investments, which is in turn owned by Cuscaden Peak &ndash a consortium comprising Temasek&rsquo s CLA Real Estate Holdings and Mapletree Investments. Cuscaden Peak and its subsidiaries, which own 61.5 per cent of the Reit&rsquo s units, will abstain from voting at the above meetings.
The scheme consideration of S$0.98 per unit represents a premium over Paragon Reit&rsquo s net asset value as at end-2024 and exceeds the trust&rsquo s highest price ever traded in the two-year period prior to the announcement of the proposed privatisation.
Paragon&rsquo s upgrading conundrum
Paragon Reit&rsquo s unitholders might suffer much pain if major asset enhancement works are carried out at the trust&rsquo s key asset, Paragon.
Located along Orchard Road, high-end mall and medical suite/office property Paragon, which is over 30 years old, accounted for about 72 per cent of the trust&rsquo s property portfolio valuation as at end-2024.
Privatisation on the horizon for S-Reits with low liquidity, mostly overseas assets
Facing challenging conditions in the luxury retail environment, tenant sales at Paragon fell 5.5 per cent in 2024 compared to a year ago.
According to Paragon Reit&rsquo s manager, crown jewel Paragon&rsquo s status as a leading upscale mall is being challenged by upcoming new malls nearby and existing competing malls undergoing major upgrades.
Times Properties envisages that a major potential asset enhancement initiative (AEI) is needed to future-proof Paragon&rsquo s competitive positioning.
A potential AEI could involve among others upgrades to faç ade and interiors, reconfiguration and optimisation of retail and circulation spaces, improved connectivity and accessibility, as well as upgrades and replacement of mechanical and electrical services and equipment.
Such an exercise may require capital expenditure of between S$300 million and S$600 million, and take three to four years to complete.
According to an illustration provided by Times Properties, assuming capital expenditure of S$300 million funded by debt at a cost of 4.4 per cent per annum and a drop in Paragon&rsquo s net property income (NPI) of between 10 to 40 per cent, Paragon Reit&rsquo s adjusted distribution per unit (DPU) for 2024 would fall by between 21 and 53 per cent. For capital expenditure of S$600 million, adjusted DPU would decline by between 32 and 64 per cent.
Adjusted DPU excludes the impact of properties which Paragon Reit has since divested, namely The Rail Mall in Singapore and Figtree Grove Shopping Centre in Australia. Today, Paragon Reit&rsquo s portfolio comprises Paragon, The Clementi Mall in Singapore and the Westfield Marion Shopping Centre in Australia.
Certainly, Reit investors value receiving stable distributions and may be unwilling to stomach a massive dip in DPU.
Still, asset upgrading works on a property can help drive higher NPI and property valuation. And such works might be unavoidable for a property to remain attractive to users.
Solving the upgrading conundrum
Perhaps, a solution should be found where Paragon Reit can carry out major upgrading works at Paragon while mitigating the pain to unitholders when the works are underway.
Possibly, Paragon Reit can sell a stake in Paragon to Cuscaden Peak and use sale proceeds to help fund a potential AEI on Paragon as well as provide income support to dampen the hit to Paragon&rsquo s NPI when works are ongoing, thereby boosting DPU.
After completing upgrading works, Paragon Reit can buy back Cuscaden Peak&rsquo s stake in Paragon, thus retaking full ownership of Paragon. When buying back the said stake, Paragon Reit could raise equity, which helps boost its free float.
Sure, there may be tax leakages and other regulatory concerns relating to the above arrangements. Nonetheless, authorities can work out measures including on the tax front to support the arrangements as part of efforts to boost the competitiveness of Singapore&rsquo s listed Reit sector.
Having a successful listed Reit sector matters. A vibrant Reit sector helps support Singapore&rsquo s equities market development. And Reits can be good investments for retirees in a fast-ageing Singapore.
Various stakeholders including sponsors, managers, regulators, tax authorities, bankers, accountants and lawyers should come together and work out how Reits can efficiently undertake major AEIs without hurting DPU too adversely when the upgrading works are ongoing. This issue is especially pertinent for Reits with relatively smaller property portfolios that own older buildings.
Singapore is working hard to grow its equities market. Incentives being rolled out might help draw more new listings to the local bourse.
However, success in drawing new listings risks being undone by the privatisation and delisting of existing listed entities.
Paragon Reit is hampered by a small free float and low trading liquidity. However, Cuscaden Peak could possibly have placed out units it owns in Paragon Reit to help improve the trust&rsquo s free float.
Also, the trust could potentially raise equity on the back of an upgraded Paragon or to help buy The Woodleigh Mall in Bidadari estate, in which Cuscaden Peak Investments has ownership interest.
Sponsors and other stakeholders need to step up to help Singapore&rsquo s listed Reit sector continue growing. More needs to be done urgently to keep Reits that own high-quality property portfolios listed on the local exchange.
|
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
MrBear12
Supreme |
14-Apr-2025 13:17
Yells: "Cast all our anxieties on Jesus for He cares for us" |
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
You guys wanna risk a cash call ?
Gearing will go up with all the make over. Better take the money and say, that's none of my business anymore |
||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Goldfinger
Supreme |
14-Apr-2025 10:13
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Ok, I called up the Financial Adviser - you can block the take over either through Form A or Form B or both. I am submitting both Forms A and B, because if the vote at Form A is blocked, there will be no EGM to pass the Scheme resolution, ie takeover. For info. | ||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
Goldfinger
Supreme |
13-Apr-2025 20:24
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Do we have to complete both Proxy Form A and Proxy Form B and submit. I think we should submit Both, since a NO at either would block this? I am against and intend to vote NO to the takeover. They can pay a better and higher price if they want these prime assets. | ||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||
|
n3wbie
Elite |
07-Apr-2025 22:26
|
||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Couldnt make it to the SIAS dialogue this evening. Any kakis managed to attend? Appreciate if there are any good insights to share please. Thanks. | ||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||